Sugaronline Editorial - Fighting Goliath head-on By Meghan Sapp

Published: 03/17/2017, 2:57:00 PM

Coca Cola has set itself up as the bad guy in the Philippines over the HFCS import spat, leaving itself with few moves that won't jeopardise its reputation for a long time to come.

Coca Cola has set itself up as the bad guy in the Philippines over the HFCS import spat, leaving itself with few moves that won't jeopardise its reputation for a long time to come.


In a classic David and Goliath story, the Philippines’ sugar industry is battling Coca Cola Femsa head-on for what the cane farmers and sugar producers see as a struggle over for their livelihoods. High fructose corn syrup imports cost sugar producers US$212 million in 2016, they say, leading the Sugar Regulatory Authority to step in and regulate HFCS to protect the industry.

Not surprisingly, Coca Cola Femsa sought a temporary restraining order against the SRA’s rule that heavily regulated HFCS imports and classifies them as “C” quota sugars , reserve sugar rather than sugar for use in the domestic market. So in turn, SRA fought back with a legal opposition against the TRO request. Now the TRO request is up for a second hearing on March 20 after a judge refused to make a ruling on March 10, saying more information was needed.

The question of HFCS imports and their impacts on the sugar industry have, if anything, forced the industry to look hard at itself, its efficiency, its capacity to compete with other sweeteners, and the impacts on the millions of small farmers and farm workers who depend on sugarcane for their livelihood. They’re not easy questions and what to do with the hard answers will pave the way for the future of the industry.

But in the meantime, the issue has become extremely divisive, as any good David and Goliath story is, with the big guy pitched against the little guy. With Coca Cola Femsa taking the legal route from the start, issuing a cease and desist letter to the sugar industry back in January to try to end public complaints about the impacts of HFCS imports, it set itself up as the bad guy. That put everyone on alert, which later led to calls by Senators to look closer at the HFCS issue and eventually led to the new regulations that Coca Cola Femsa is fighting so vehemently against.

So is there any surprise that there would be calls for a boycott against soft drinks as well? There shouldn’t be. Why then would the agriculture minister publicly suggest that the import restrictions be lifted, raising questions as to possible ties with the company rather than supporting the farmers he is charged to protect?

The lines are clearly drawn and any wrong move could result in a public relations backfire for Coca Cola and HFCS overall. They must tread carefully on Monday or risk the entire country rising up against them for going after the helpless little farmer.

:: Recent Reports

pdfSugaronline Editorial - You need to keep that up By Meghan Sapp2017/05/19
pdfSugaronline Editorial - You go, girl! By Meghan Sapp2017/05/12
pdfSugaronline Editorial - Vaya 5 de Mayo By Meghan Sapp2017/05/05
pdfSugaronline Editorial - Looking to 2020 By Meghan Sapp2017/05/02
pdfSugaronline Editorial - Everyone is going to die! By Meghan Sapp2017/04/21
pdfSugaronline Editorial - Clumsy fingers By Meghan Sapp2017/03/31
pdfSugaronline Editorial - Taking another stab at getting it right By Meghan Sapp2017/03/24
pdfSugaronline Editorial - Fighting Goliath head-on By Meghan Sapp2017/03/17
pdfSugaronline Editorial - Once upon a time in Mexico By Meghan Sapp2017/03/10
pdfSugaronline Editorial - Kinda, sorta, maybe, all right then, fine! By Meghan Sapp2017/03/03
pdfSugaronline Editorial - Feeling quite special By Meghan Sapp2017/02/27
pdfSugaronline Editorial - From Russia with love By Meghan Sapp2017/02/17
pdfSugaronline Editorial - The problem with Mexico By Meghan Sapp2017/02/10
pdfSugaronline Editorial - New sheriff in town By Meghan Sapp2017/01/30
pdfSugaronline Editorial - Bagasse means business By Meghan Sapp2017/01/20
pdfSugaronline Editorial - Place your bets By Meghan Sapp2017/01/13
pdfSugaronline Editorial - Tinkering fools By Meghan Sapp2017/01/06
pdfSugaronline Editorial - A peek into the future By Meghan Sapp2016/12/16
pdfSugaronline Editorial - Breathing a sigh of relief By Meghan Sapp2016/12/09
pdfSugaronline Editorial - Preaching to the choir By Meghan Sapp2016/12/05
pdfSugaronline Editorial - The Big 2-5 By Meghan Sapp2016/11/28
pdfSugaronline Editorial - Feeling sensitive By Meghan Sapp2016/11/18
pdfSugaronline Editorial - Bad week for sugar By Meghan Sapp2016/11/11
pdfSugaronline Editorial - Trump Card By Meghan Sapp2016/11/07
pdfSugaronline Editorial - Trick or Treat By Meghan Sapp2016/10/28
1 of 31